An argument against spanking children as a form of discipline

Spanking once may have been acceptable, but new research out of the university of texas, and published in the journal of family psychology, offers proof that laying a hand on your child as a form. Discipline the kids parents are suppose to raise kids that obey the rules discipline, acts as punishment for breaking rules just as with adults, the discipline should depend on what rule was broken. While most people (at least publicly) decry the use of spanking as a form of child discipline, more people do spank their kids than they let on instead, many spanking opponents still justify swats or smacks or even popping of the hands or head as different than spanking. Excerpt from essay : against spanking as a way of disciplining children spanking is a subject that has sparked controversy for a long time the debate has been raging in academic circles, among caregivers and psychologists alike.

A i'm glad you wrote in with this question, since this is an area of concern for many parents the definition of child abuse and the line between child abuse and child discipline is a legal matter that differs from state to state (within the us) and from country to country. Spanking argument #1 - spanking is an effective way to manage behavior hitting a small child will usually stop misbehavior temporarily however, other ways of discipline such as verbal correction, reasoning and time-out work as well and do not have the potential for harm that hitting does. Discipline without spanking the next time you feel the urge to spank, take a deep breath instead and consider what you want your child to learn.

The cases for and against spanking of young children are many and diverse but the main issue is the level of correctness that the act of spanking can reach the issue with spanking is that many americans do think it is needed to raise a child the “right way”, and some believe it is an act of abuse. How effective is spanking as a discipline for children when parents are angry the purpose of spanking is not for parents to express their anxiety or frustration anger places destructive fear into discipline how effective is spanking as discipline for children when biblical principles are followed spanking is effective as a method of. Spanking is a quick, knee-jerk reaction, while thinking about discipline takes time and can be difficult but it is worth it: effective discipline encourages a healthy relationship between you and your child, which is what parents want and children need. Stop spanking: save the children spanking has been used for many years and it must come to an end also known as corporal punishment, spanking is most often used as a form of discipline although it is said to have some benefits, the negative consequences far outweigh the good.

Perhaps there are better forms of discipline and perhaps violent parents promote violent children, but it is possible and probable that a well-placed well administered spanking does more good than harm. Spanking to discipline a child sparks heated debate that reflects deep divides in our society studies generally show negative effects of spanking, but there are many caveats. Continued discipline techniques what you choose may depend on the type of inappropriate behavior your child displays, your child's age, your child's temperament, and your parenting style.

Form of punishment as a response to disobedient children12 tegrating the biblical text with modern conceptions of child discipline13 adah maurer and james s wallerstein take an extreme position and claim argument for the corporal punishment of children. It is ineffective: spanking a child will stop the child from misbehaving for the moment, but studies have shown that the child's compliance will only last for a short time corporal punishment actually increases the child's non-compliant behavior in the futurepsychologist h stephen glenn said corporal punishment is the least effective method [of discipline. And spanking an older child is proof in itself that this form of punishment isn't working: you should be able to control your pre-teen's behavior by reasoning with him, not hitting him experts have also found that over time, spanking makes a child angry and resentful and less -- not more -- willing to do what you ask. The arguments against spanking are hardly new shortly after christ, plutarch taught, “children ought to be lead to honorable practices by encouragement and reasoning, and most certainly not by blows and ill treatment. Domestic corporal punishment, ie the punishment of children by their parents, is often referred to colloquially as spanking, smacking or slapping it has been outlawed in an increasing number of countries, starting with sweden in 1966.

an argument against spanking children as a form of discipline Corporal punishment at home — spanking can be an appropriate form of child discipline i was 8 years old and living with my grandparents when i first saw my aunt beat her son when he refused to finish his mealthat was the first time i had seen an adult administer ‘corporal punishment at home’ on a child.

Spanking essay examples 10 total results an overview of child discipline and the concept of spanking as a method of punishment 1,727 words 4 pages an argument against the use of spanking as a disciplinary method 603 words 1 page an introduction to the advantages and disadvantages of corporal punishment. The article examines and evaluates the commonly held belief that children must be disciplined (controlled) by parents and teachers semantic imprecisions in books authored by discipline advocates are illustrated, and more precise definitions are provided for such terms as discipline, authority, power, control and influence. Spanking is often looked at as a violent form of discipline that is never necessary to control a child some feel that spanking or corporal punishment can often lead to child abuse it is felt that if a parent spanks their child once, it will be easier to do it again and again for any discipline problem, no matter how mild or severe. The case against spanking spanking your child as a form of punishment is very questionable nowadays, a lot of people think it is ok to spank your child and others disagree there have been many researches done about this and it is a very controversial topic.

  • While many adults would argue that hitting people is wrong, spanking children continues to be used as an acceptable form of discipline because many parents think spanking will teach children not to do things that are forbidden, stop them quickly when they are being irritating, and encourage them to do what they should.
  • Corporal punishment does not teach child to behave appropriately learn what the problems are with it and what you should do to discipline your children all forms of corporal punishment are quick, knee-jerk reactions, while thinking about discipline takes time and can be difficult hyman, irwin, the case against spanking: how to.

In my own opinion, i do agree with you that as parents we are obliged to discipline our children but i was not exactly sure what you were saying your stance was on the point of the argument. The case against spanking in canada to use force to discipline a child in the moment or when a child stops responding to milder forms of hitting, the hits get harder and injuries become. Those times, she says, include: “repeated offenses where my child’s safety is in danger, lying, and repeated acts of disobedience after other forms of discipline have been used” proponents of occasional spanking say that it can provide an instant solution when dealing with an unruly preschooler.

an argument against spanking children as a form of discipline Corporal punishment at home — spanking can be an appropriate form of child discipline i was 8 years old and living with my grandparents when i first saw my aunt beat her son when he refused to finish his mealthat was the first time i had seen an adult administer ‘corporal punishment at home’ on a child. an argument against spanking children as a form of discipline Corporal punishment at home — spanking can be an appropriate form of child discipline i was 8 years old and living with my grandparents when i first saw my aunt beat her son when he refused to finish his mealthat was the first time i had seen an adult administer ‘corporal punishment at home’ on a child. an argument against spanking children as a form of discipline Corporal punishment at home — spanking can be an appropriate form of child discipline i was 8 years old and living with my grandparents when i first saw my aunt beat her son when he refused to finish his mealthat was the first time i had seen an adult administer ‘corporal punishment at home’ on a child. an argument against spanking children as a form of discipline Corporal punishment at home — spanking can be an appropriate form of child discipline i was 8 years old and living with my grandparents when i first saw my aunt beat her son when he refused to finish his mealthat was the first time i had seen an adult administer ‘corporal punishment at home’ on a child.
An argument against spanking children as a form of discipline
Rated 4/5 based on 26 review

2018.